Silent Night, Bloody Night (1974)

Author: Brett H.
Submitted by: Brett H.   Date : 2008-12-13 12:34

Directed by: Theodore Gershuny
Written by: Theodore Gershuny, Jeffrey Konvitz & Ira Teller
Starring: Patrick O'Neal, James Patterson, Mary Woronov, Philip Bruns & John Carradine

Reviewed by: Brett H.

ďOne last time, I have to see this ground. Itís beautiful now, as if nothing had happened here. Soon, they will tear down the main house and then nothing will be left. Nothing. Except what I remember.Ē

Iíve never been one to worry about where a film gathers its inspiration; Iím more concerned about the overall quality of the product. John Carpenterís Halloween set the slasher world on fire in 1978 and has been criticized over the years from heavily borrowing from the earlier work of Bob Clark in his 1974 Canadian epic, Black Christmas. Theyíre both great movies, and thatís all I need to know. Besides, if I confined all my props to Bob Clark, Iíd be forgetting a little film released before the flagship Maple Leaf slasher called Silent Night, Bloody Night. You can pull out your Black Christmas checklist right now and gander at the attributes and check off plenty that Silent Night, Bloody Night also contains. If you can believe it, Silent Night, Bloody Night actually has seen more DVD releases than Clarkís movie, but the con is theyíre all public domain shoddy releases. The bright side? The average price paid for the film is well under a dollar. Is it a worthy stocking stuffer, or should this one be promptly roasted on an open fire?

Small town secrets are often the most interesting, and the events that went down at the Butler home are a prime example. On Christmas Eve, 1950, a man emerges from a large white house engulfed in flames and promptly falls to the snow in agony, burned to death. Inside, a funeral song plays on the organ while the Christmas embers burn in the fireplace, a view of the burning corpse can be seen through the window. The deceased man, Wilfred Butler (Philip Bruns) leaves his estate to his only living relative, his grandson, Jeffrey (James Patterson) on the condition that the house is left alone as it stands. Years later, Jeffrey needs some money and decides to sell the house, sending his lawyer to deal with matter. Townspeople desperately want the house to be demolished and finally theyíre given the out. While everyone is hoping for a White Christmas, an escaped mental patient from the loony bin stirs up a bit of a panic. A series of twists, turns, truths and a brutal axe massacre makes this Christmas resemble squished holly rather than pure white snowÖ

Silent Night, Bloody Night is actually an engaging, cheap slasher that proved to be slightly ahead of its time. No one goes in expecting too much from public domain cheapies, but often enough youíll get one that surprises you, and thatís precisely what happens here. The similarities to Black Christmas are definitely there, from the snarly phone calls, Christmas setting, POV shots to general slasher mayhem. The two would actually make quite the double feature of seasonís slayings. Just when you think things canít get any better, you see Mr. Cameo himself, John Carradineís name in the credits and nostalgic cheapie fans canít help but grin. From start to finish, the flick grasps the viewer by the throat and doesnít let go. At one point during the climax, things get a little far fetched, but that is something easily overlooked in a film of this nature.

The strongest element the film has going for it is the fact that it was made before the slasher boom hit and therefore doesnít exist entirely within the rules that became standard. Revenge is a key motive in the film, but unlike Prom Night and countless other slashers, the theme of vengeance isnít used as merely a motive to put the knife in a killerís hand to cut up cuties. Instead, the mystery unravels with the characters and viewer both not knowing what comes next, adding extra oomph to the occasional severed hand and a sensational axe massacre by the black-gloved madman. Between guessing who the killer could be, plot twists and the slow revelations of the backstory, thereís little time to sit around bored. All the while, presents are wrapped, Christmas trees blink and the filmís score plays on that eternal classic, Silent Night.

From a directorial standpoint, there are many wonderful establishing shots of the mansion and the lighting is dim and eerie throughout. Depth plays a nice role in the film as cold, leafless trees are abundant, the shadows of the old house shrouding the mysteries along with a creepy graveyard making sure to keep the film relatively high in atmosphere. And, what would be a slasher without a few good red herrings? The acting is sometimes a tad stiff and the dialogue is nothing to brag about, yet it still pleasantly keeps its head well above water for the short 81-minute runtime. One of the more enjoyable moments of the film is a sepia-toned flashback scene involving mental patients getting loose and going on a rampage in the asylum, seeking revenge on the doctors that kept them locked up. The picture quality gets a bit rougher during this scene, which helps it become even more tense and unnerving.

The disc I viewed is from Brentwood Entertainment, the first true king of the DVD value pack, from their Vault of Horror 10 movie collection. The video is what youíd expect, old school full frame VHS-style charm with some incredibly dark scenes, blemishes and a yellow vertical line running down the screen for a moment here and a longer moment there. The audio on the other hand is surprisingly clear, free of hiss other than the very odd cackle. Is Silent Night, Bloody Night going to take away from the thunder of tried and true classics like Black Christmas and Silent Night, Deadly Night? Probably not, especially for the former, but in my mind, itís the perfect Christmas themed slasher that is probably already in many collections just waiting to be discovered. If it turns up in your stalking, donít hesitate to give it a spin. Buy it!

comments powered by Disqus Ratings:
Average members rating (out of 10) : Not yet rated   
Votes : 0